Debate Over Psych Meds in Nursing Homes

How dangerous are psychiatric medications when they’re prescribed for dementia patients in nursing homes? According to a recent article in Modern Healthcare, the benefits of the long-term use of psych meds when they’re prescribed for the disorders for which they’re designed—would “need to be colossal to counter known harms associated with their use.” And while the off-label use of antipsychotics to treat dementia symptoms appears to have declined, it remains a significant problem in Southern California and throughout the country.


Stopping Use of Psychotropic Drugs

Researchers across the globe are speaking out about the dangers of antipsychotic drugs. To be sure, a debate about their efficacy and long-term effects recently sprung up on the website for the journal of the British Medical Association. According to Dr. Peter Gøtzsche, who serves as the director of the Nordic Cochrane Center, the lack of benefit from these medications, particularly when they’re used in an off-label manner, means that “we could stop almost all psychotropic drugs without causing harm.” For even when they’re used to provide short-term relief, he emphasized, they pose serious long-term harms.

In the United States, psychotropic medications simply are overprescribed. A study featured in JAMA Psychiatry in 2012 reported that “rates of patients visiting their doctors for a prescription for antipsychotics more than doubled . . . between 1993 and 2009.” And those figures represent one of the growing problems of these drugs—they’re used far too often in nursing homes “to manage challenging behaviors in elderly dementia patients.”

To be clear, antipsychotic drugs weren’t designed to treat or manage symptoms linked to Alzheimer’s disease and other forms of dementia. When the drugs are prescribed for reasons other than those approved by the FDA, we describe this situation as “off-label” use.

Antipsychotic Drug Use Inside and Outside Nursing Homes

While many elder care advocates as well as federal health officials have attempted to limit the use of psychotropic drugs for dementia patients, it’s important to recognize that this abuse isn’t solely taking place in nursing homes. Indeed, a recent report from the Government Accountability Office showed that “overuse among the elderly is not exclusive to nursing homes.” Rather, “internists, family medicine physicians, psychiatrists, and neurologists wrote more than 80 percent of the prescriptions for antipsychotics for older adults with dementia in 2012.”

In other words, even when older adults are living at home with caregivers, the off-label use of antipsychotic drugs to manage dementia symptoms continue to be a problem. And in 2012, the Medicare prescription drug program ended up paying around $363 million for antipsychotic drugs prescribed for elderly dementia patients.

While some physicians argue that these medications are “working well for people with dementia,” others cite the numerous adverse events that occur each year as a result of taking these drugs, from overdoses to severe brain injuries. Other side-effects for the elderly can include “increased risk of heart failure, sudden death, and pneumonia.”

Do you have concerns about your elderly loved one’s care in a San Diego nursing home or assisted living facility? An experienced San Diego elder abuse attorney can answer your questions today.

Photo Credit: nic0 via Compfight cc

See Related Blog Posts:

Elder Abuse or Medical Malpractice?

Proposed Legislation for RCFE Reform and Excluded Persons Lists

Contact Information